Emily,
Gene seldom pop by the thread as her AD was over. She has drop the link to her experience in one of her posting above.
Just my 3 cents' worth. In service line, there tends to be both positive and negative comments coz we all have different expectations. Over here, there are both happy and unhappy brides sharing. I thought the bottom line should be whether you are comfortable working with your coordinator and whether you want to place your trust on them. Whichever venue you choose, there is bound to be complaints. Coz we want the once-in-a-lifetime event to be a perfect one.
You have to experience for yourself whether they are good or not.
The reason why i chose Hyatt is of course because of the theme. But i find Zona, my coordinator, a very professional one. Before i signed up with Hyatt, i asked her outrightly about the probs that Gene faced. She did not side with hotel, but said that was a "one-time" off incident. She also counter-proposed ways to avoid such hiccups.
Well, maybe you should just drop by again and share with them your concerns.