John :
Just to share a few opinions.
*Everybody keeps saying focus on myself , look at myself first but nothing concrete. So what mistake did I make?*
- the pedestrian who was knocked down by drunk driver & a life is gone just like that !what mistake did that pedestrian make ?
- the wife, who husband chose to cheat on many times despite how good the wife is, what mistake did that wife make ?
- young girls who were raped by step father or bro even with the help of their own mum, what mistake did these young girls make ?
- Teens being raped and ended up in IMH ? what mistake did they make ?
The mistake you make is you are too idealistic & u ve ur own set of black/white thinking that a wife must behave in certain ways. Well, humans are imperfect. You claimed how she treat your kids. But to me is nothing, she is not perfect herself, and if she is really suffering from depression, the lack of certain chemical in her brain may cause her to lost control as well.
I have a girl friend,who has depression & when she lost control, & the kid is noisy/naughty, she will lost control & take the cloth hanger to hit him until bleeding! At times, she may shout till neighbours come over to ask what happened..Her hubby, instead of blame her or condemn her, bring her to see doctor & realised she has post natal depression & try to support her as best as he can. That is true giving...true understanding in Action. Her condition improves now..Her hubby is sensitive to her needs & take concrete action to help her & not like you, Only know how to be "fixed" in a thinking, how wrong /horrible she is..
The mistake u make is u keep attack her bad points and not take the advice to bring her see a doctor. Jolly well, she could just be having depression & may improve with medication help.
You may seem to be a good husband, but to me not really so...a good husband who really do things from their heart will do it UNCONDITIONALLY & not do already than expect "returns". IF spouse is appreciative it is a bonus to us, if they are not, either u tel her what u want to get from her OR u just accept the way she is and continue to love her unconditionally.
You want her to at least admit she is wrong - Without her sorry, you cant breathe is it ? Let me tel u, not many pp can say SORRY easily ok. I may be wrong, but i think u r also quite a insecure man who constantly need her approval.
Actually, if u r really that good, u will have been humble & not defensive to others advice to you. Be open minded...
* bring her see doctor
* follow up on marriage counsellor
* write her a letter
* tel her what u feel/think
I can tel u, NO ONE will bother to self reflect in life UNLESS a major trauma happened in their life. MAYBE U PASSED AWAY SUDDENLY DUE TO HEART ATTACK WHEN QUARRELLING WITH HER , that may cause her to reflect !!
So out of the blue moon, u want forumer to talk to your wife, I think she will only feel insulted/ anger.....
Have it ever occured to you, what u do for her, she is thankful in her heart but for some reasons, she cant express that thanks to you, but feel more "comfortable" to treat u in negative way ? And if she really have depression, all the more she cant even thank you properly.
U do things for her than dun expect returns. This is true giving.
And instead of focus on "how much i ve done for her ", "she really treat me like shit", " she so lucky to hv me "....why not just think ? = Maybe what i have done is simply not even good enough in her eyes ? Maybe there is even unresolved anger that she hold against you ?
Just trying to help. And if you want to be defensive, go ahead. But ultimately, your health will never be better even your wife is not with you do u know why ??
Cos whatever pp try to help you, u r just -ve. U take things too personal...and soon, anger will built up in you and soon more sickness.....DUN say your wife attitude lead u to bad health....
IT COULD just be yourself, your own perception/distorted way of thinking that cause your health problems as well....
Come on!. She went thru labour pain to give you children....NOT every woman can go thru tat ok ! Isnt that the best thank you gift/appreciation she gives to you ?
Is either you love her enough to stand by her...
but dun put her down...IF i am her....I will feel disgusted /angry that my husband, on one hand try to treat me like queen, but behind my back, put me down as if i m a very horrible monster.......
Wish you all the best