Hi all,
Recently, there are a few emails to me asking me why I mentioned that 21st Nov is not a good day for marriage even though the Tong Shu says so. I've addressed this sometimes back in a thread, but i will post it here again to answer anyone's doubts and for those who had missed my earlier post.
-------------------------------------------------
21/11/09 is indeed listed in the Tong Shu as auspicious date for wedding. As i always explain to my clients, if you know how to read 3 chinese character words, you will know how to select dates yourself from the tong shu. All you need to know is "Yi, Jia Qu", which means "Good, For Marriage".
So this date is indeed listed as "Good, For Marriage' in the Tong Shu. BUT on that page of the Tong Shu, it consist of many many more other Chinese characters that many people did not take into account for. There is this particular one row in the Tong Shu that tells you if this particular day is good for what purpose. This is very important. Normally for wedding, we want to choose "Chen", which means Success Day; or other compatible days for wedding such as "Ding" (stable day), "Zhi" (initiate day) etc etc. This will ensure this day selected is good for the purpose of wedding, even if it is just a general good day. Tong Shu ASSUMES you know how to filter this out yourself. But most people don't do it.
So that brings us back to the date 21/11/09. This day is listed as "Wei" in the Tong Shu, which means Danger Day! A Danger day is a day that is not suitable for any important activities. And to me, marriage is a very important activity. The calculation cannot have any mistakes. I want to be "kiasu" for all my clients and make sure the dates selected for them are really the best.
So even here in the forum, for those of you who had asked me for general wedding dates, the dates I've given to all not only avoid clashes to both the bride, the groom and the parents, I have ALSO taken into account this factor by filtering out the unsuitable dates for you. Which is why some of you might have noticed the dates i gave are significantly lesser than what you might find from the Tong Shu. And this also explains why I said that 21st Nov 09 is NOT a good day for marriage.
-------------------------------------------------
However, do note that I am saying this from the perspective of a GENERAL good date only. If your date is calculated using Bazi, which is the correct and authentic method of date selection, then that day might still be good for you. This is why Bazi date selection is very different from a Tong Shu date selection. Tong Shu date selection is too general and more for "mass consumption". If your master calculates the dates for you using Bazi, then yes, perhaps he did take your Bazi into account to derive that 21st Nov is good for both of you from the Bazi perspective. If only the Tong Shu is used, then unfortunately, this is not an ideal general date for wedding purpose.
I hope this clears up any doubts you might have