Hi viv,
My Fh is catholic and I'm a not-baptised Christian, for that reason I was not able to get married in the protestant church that we attend together. I just want to let you know that depending on parish priests, not all of them require you to sign a pre-nup to raise your children as Catholics. Some of them use the term "raise them in the Christian faith", and leave it to the couple to decide the definition.
I initially was apprehesive about getting married in a Catholic ceremony because of this too. But the priest whom spoke to us was very understanding and asked me do I have any reservations about raising children in the christian faith, I replied No, and he said that was enough for him to accept our request to officiate us already. A wedding service can be held and there will be no mention of Mary. To an outsider, it will be no great difference from a christian wedding.
It depends on what you believe in and what you want to fight for. If you can accept that it is the same God that you pray to and invite to witness in your HM regardless of church type, then you may want to consider a catholic church. If you really cannot accept then you can look for a pastor willing to officate you outside of a church building (again not all pastors/protestant churches agree to this).
When I was searching for a protestant venue for my wedding, I found out that Trueway Baptist Church in Queenstown allows non-members to book and use their venue. You may even approach their pastor to officiate you. But think they also require at least one party to be a baptised christian. But the rental is high ~$1000.
Let me know if you need any help regarding this. Hope that everything will work out for you eventually.
Hi life,
Sorry to hear what you have to go thru. Just to share that the pastor of the church I attend (with my FH) did not allow us to get married there because I am not baptised yet and we are not officially members of the church, only regular visitors. This was in order not to send out wrong signals to the congregation as my FH is a catholic. The other pastor whom took us thru the marriage counselling course in church was willing to help us officiate my wedding on his own capacity (without involving the church at a last resort-no cert from church or signing church register) and he also cannot do ROM. He told us to find a protestant church venue that will allow me to use so that it is easier for him as he did not want to be seem going against his main pastor by marrying us at any other buildings.
In the end, I did not want to have all the diff logistics to handle and to trouble that pastor, so I settled for a plan B. Maybe you can ask your pastor his reasons, or ask him to help you reccomend other pastors whom may be able to help you instead.